It was renewed because when you subscribe to something in Paypal it creates a rule
in your Paypal account
to regularly send the money, like a standing order in your bank account, until you cancel the subscription.

Which you can do in your Paypal account at any time.

There is nothing we can do about you voluntarily sending us money, other than fix your group membership on here if the link between Paypal and us is broken, which it is for many people these days.

I have manually done yours now, as I and Scott and Brian and so on have for many people when they highlight a problem.

We have been trying to resolve this on and off for
years
thanks to the mess of code and hacks that have lead the Paypal subscription mechanism to fall to bits.

You have instructed Paypal to regularly send us money, uninstruct them if you want to stop! We literally have no method of stopping your end of it.
