Rev2 tubby vs 911 GT2

Tales of driving experiences you have had.


Moderators: IMOC Moderators, IMOC Committee Members

This post is:

Stupid
0
No votes
 
Total votes: 0

luthor1
Posts: 2452
Joined: Sat Nov 05, 2005 7:03 pm
Location: Southampton

Re: Rev2 tubby vs 911 GT2

Post by luthor1 »

Nismo turned over 504 million Euro's last year
Porsche turned over 3,200 million Euro's last year.

I think you think Nismo is smaller than that... remember ALL Nismo do are make cars go faster. I'd wager that they are better at it than Porsche who have to spend a greater % on marketing and car design etc.
User avatar
Lauren
IMOC Committee
Posts: 38632
Joined: Mon Dec 13, 2004 5:37 pm
Location: Greater Manchester
Contact:

Re: Rev2 tubby vs 911 GT2

Post by Lauren »

luthor1 wrote:Yeah - Nismo, they are a real tuppeny-hapenny outfit!

:whistle:


Well yes there is thatI admit. A GT3RS or a Nismo Z tune, what would i have?

GT3RS. No contest.

/not that i'll ever be able to afford one.
2020 GR Yaris - Circuit Pack :lover:
Bibbs
Posts: 352
Joined: Sat Dec 18, 2004 4:16 pm
Location: Reading, UK

Re: Rev2 tubby vs 911 GT2

Post by Bibbs »

Comparing the Z Tune is the same as seeing what Gemballa or Ruf do to the 911.

RT12 anyone? 225mph and 650hp.

And one went past me at Nur last year .. it was one of my highlights being overtaken by it.
User avatar
Lauren
IMOC Committee
Posts: 38632
Joined: Mon Dec 13, 2004 5:37 pm
Location: Greater Manchester
Contact:

Re: Rev2 tubby vs 911 GT2

Post by Lauren »

Bibbs wrote:Comparing the Z Tune is the same as seeing what Gemballa or Ruf do to the 911.

RT12 anyone? 225mph and 650hp.

And one went past me at Nur last year .. it was one of my highlights being overtaken by it.


Exactly. You are comparing a non-production modified car to a production car.

Always better to buy a non-modded car IMO. Modifying is a mugs game to a large extent. It can be fun though.

/been there got the t-shirt.
2020 GR Yaris - Circuit Pack :lover:
Bibbs
Posts: 352
Joined: Sat Dec 18, 2004 4:16 pm
Location: Reading, UK

Re: Rev2 tubby vs 911 GT2

Post by Bibbs »

As much as I'd like to argue with Miss Understeer Lamppost here, I agree.

(Having just spent £4k on a blower for his S2000)
luthor1
Posts: 2452
Joined: Sat Nov 05, 2005 7:03 pm
Location: Southampton

Re: Rev2 tubby vs 911 GT2

Post by luthor1 »

We have to draw a rather solid lin between home-brew tuning and Nismo/Mugen/Ruf/Alpina/Brabus etc. I agree home-brew can be, how can I put this, fragile? But outfits like these can produce a 100% balanced vehicle which removes the compromise the factory built in and focus's the car in the direction the customer wants.
luthor1
Posts: 2452
Joined: Sat Nov 05, 2005 7:03 pm
Location: Southampton

Re: Rev2 tubby vs 911 GT2

Post by luthor1 »

I think people (quite naturally) are very happy to make money-for-money comparisons. If you have an 80k GT3 then you can spend 40k on your evo FQ400 and still compare them.

That's just logical - to compare what you can buy, with, well, what you can buy... A Nismo GTR is made specifically to do exactly what the GT3RS is designed to do isn't it?
splashnatz
Posts: 2068
Joined: Thu Feb 24, 2005 12:23 pm
Location: LEEDS

Re: Rev2 tubby vs 911 GT2

Post by splashnatz »

Of course you can compare them. They're both cars. You can compare an F1 car to a Nissan Micra. (F1 car is fast, Micra is good for shopping trips). That comparison is fair, and shows the plus points with both vehicles.

GT3RS is a stripped-out track orientated car. Probably one of the worst "road" cars Porsche currently produce. Nismo Z tune is a spectacular example of Jap-Tec.

Has anybody looked for performance comparisons of them ? I bet they're really closely matched when timed round the nurburgring.


hang on ... just re-read the title - this is about the GT2 not the GT3RS. It's gone waaaaay off topic now !
User avatar
Lauren
IMOC Committee
Posts: 38632
Joined: Mon Dec 13, 2004 5:37 pm
Location: Greater Manchester
Contact:

Re: Rev2 tubby vs 911 GT2

Post by Lauren »

splashnatz wrote:
GT3RS is a stripped-out track orientated car. Probably one of the worst "road" cars Porsche currently produce. Nismo Z tune is a spectacular example of Jap-Tec.


Well actually a GT3RS seemed pretty liveable on the road. Yes its got a cage and bucket seats. Its when it goes onto the track though it just feels so much the race car.

It'd be the absolute perfect car for a trip to the Ring and back.
2020 GR Yaris - Circuit Pack :lover:
James Junior
Posts: 916
Joined: Wed Apr 12, 2006 1:04 pm
Location: Manchester

Re: Rev2 tubby vs 911 GT2

Post by James Junior »

OMFG that is ridiculous - that Supra was incredible but that Skyline actually had me laughing out loud! That is insane! The guy was soiling himself! (I would)

A car that is too fast for a racetrack - where do you go from there?!?

Equally my girlfriend sitting next to me now thinks I am a bigger geek than she did already...
User avatar
Lauren
IMOC Committee
Posts: 38632
Joined: Mon Dec 13, 2004 5:37 pm
Location: Greater Manchester
Contact:

Re: Rev2 tubby vs 911 GT2

Post by Lauren »

James Junior wrote:OMFG that is ridiculous - that Supra was incredible but that Skyline actually had me laughing out loud! That is insane! The guy was soiling himself! (I would)

A car that is too fast for a racetrack - where do you go from there?!?

Equally my girlfriend sitting next to me now thinks I am a bigger geek than she did already...


Really powerful cars obviously aren't suited so well to tight twisty tracks such as the one in the vid. They can however be fully exploited at the bigger circuits, not a problem.
2020 GR Yaris - Circuit Pack :lover:
Quigonjay
Posts: 11294
Joined: Mon Feb 14, 2005 8:43 pm
Location: Blackburn

Re: Rev2 tubby vs 911 GT2

Post by Quigonjay »



was looking forward to watching that but the wonky camera made me dizzy after about 10 secs :shaking2:
skinthespin
Posts: 1833
Joined: Tue Jan 25, 2005 11:04 pm
Location: Derbyshire

Re: Rev2 tubby vs 911 GT2

Post by skinthespin »

Agree with Lauren in that if I had 80k to spend on a car i'd have a GT3RS over ANY modified Jap car, to say the performance is in a different league though is just daft, dont eh 911 and Skyline lap the Ring in similar times? Certaily both just under 8 minutes, so they are both very quick and both very capable and on the same planet performance wise, if all your measureing is raw speed.

The Jap cars will always be more compromised because of what they start out in life as, economy shopping cars usually, or overweight GT's that need 500bhp to get them going well, and I would say Porsche has more expertise than pretty much any car company when it comes to making cars go fast, just look at there racing history, on top of that they have been developing the 911 for 40 years, so you would expect it to be good.

Is a 911 better than a modified jap car? For me yes, for a lot of you no, for me its more than pure speed, its breeding and its finesse, neither of which jap cars have.
User avatar
Lauren
IMOC Committee
Posts: 38632
Joined: Mon Dec 13, 2004 5:37 pm
Location: Greater Manchester
Contact:

Re: Rev2 tubby vs 911 GT2

Post by Lauren »

skinthespin wrote:Agree with Lauren in that if I had 80k to spend on a car i'd have a GT3RS over ANY modified Jap car, to say the performance is in a different league though is just daft, dont eh 911 and Skyline lap the Ring in similar times? Certaily both just under 8 minutes, so they are both very quick and both very capable and on the same planet performance wise, if all your measureing is raw speed.

The Jap cars will always be more compromised because of what they start out in life as, economy shopping cars usually, or overweight GT's that need 500bhp to get them going well, and I would say Porsche has more expertise than pretty much any car company when it comes to making cars go fast, just look at there racing history, on top of that they have been developing the 911 for 40 years, so you would expect it to be good.

Is a 911 better than a modified jap car? For me yes, for a lot of you no, for me its more than pure speed, its breeding and its finesse, neither of which jap cars have.


Agree totally.
2020 GR Yaris - Circuit Pack :lover:
Antstarr
Posts: 822
Joined: Thu Jun 08, 2006 9:26 am
Location: London baybee!!

Re: Rev2 tubby vs 911 GT2

Post by Antstarr »

Then automatically this post comes down to 1 conclusion.

There are obviously a majority of fast cars out there on the road for track use as well as being able to go fast on all types of road use. But its really down to opinion and what the driver actually wants. (Agree with me Lauren) just do it!!

If I wanted a track car I would pick a Noble, goes faster on acceleration and top speed and is made for track, smaller engine but produces more power and torque and lighter?
Looks better as well plus its cheaper by about 30k. If not that then id spend it on the M15 which is a better spec than the 400 yet only around 70k.

However I would not justify spending such a large amount of money for something which seems a bit basic and bland but goes fast around track.

Just because Porsche have been around working on a car for such a long time does mean its good but as far as Im aware it hasnt really won anything from what im aware of. It sounds like just a high end spec of their range like a BMW M3 GTR or a AMG sportscar.

The GTR has won tonnes of championships in its time since the R32 and in the JGTC and has been banned from some racing cups because it was TOO GOOD! There is a reason for why its so big and yet makes such a statement.

If I had the chance i would rather pick Z tune skyline if I ever could get my hands on one or maybe even an NSX-R tuned by its home brewed Mugen company. Looking at the times and power of the Noble and the Z Nismo Skyline are far more progressive than the spec of a GT3RS and GT2.

Btw companies like Nismo and Mugen are home brewed companies, so no excuses there...they can come production just like the GT3RS.
Watashi wa Ant desu, BAKA!!!
User avatar
Lauren
IMOC Committee
Posts: 38632
Joined: Mon Dec 13, 2004 5:37 pm
Location: Greater Manchester
Contact:

Re: Rev2 tubby vs 911 GT2

Post by Lauren »

Have you ever heard of Le Mans Antstarr?

The road class is dominated by GT3s.

The porsche has been winning championships for 40 years.... who can compete with that?

Its not just about power and top speed, its so much more than that as Skin hinted at. Its about driver involvement and that feeling you get when you are in the zone and revelling in the handling of the car as you constantly push it over the limit again and again.... For me its so much more than just figures and laptimes. There is nothing bland about a GT3RS, no way...

I remember the first time my friend put his foot down as we came out of the cones and onto the first part of the Nurburgring. As the tachometer climbed to the 8500rpm redline the hairs on the back of my neck stood up. The last time they did that was when i had a ride in a Miura SV... so i knew that this car was very special.

Sure i agree its about what the driver wants, but does every driver really know what they want? If you went in a GT3RS would your perception change? Probably. Thats the point. It totally re-arranged mine and i've been in a few/driven a few cars.
2020 GR Yaris - Circuit Pack :lover:
User avatar
Lauren
IMOC Committee
Posts: 38632
Joined: Mon Dec 13, 2004 5:37 pm
Location: Greater Manchester
Contact:

Re: Rev2 tubby vs 911 GT2

Post by Lauren »

Antstarr wrote:
The GTR has won tonnes of championships in its time since the R32 and in the JGTC and has been banned from some racing cups because it was TOO GOOD! There is a reason for why its so big and yet makes such a statement.


Actually its really not unusual for cars to dominate their class and then effectively suffer at the hands of those who make the rules. Look at the E36 BTTC who had to run weight penalties because they were dominating the championship, largely due to being RWD as opposed to the FWD competition.
2020 GR Yaris - Circuit Pack :lover:
skinthespin
Posts: 1833
Joined: Tue Jan 25, 2005 11:04 pm
Location: Derbyshire

Re: Rev2 tubby vs 911 GT2

Post by skinthespin »

It really does depend on you outlook on the finer things in life, its the difference between drinking a fine wine (I know nothing about wines) matured over many years with an ecsquisite taste that only the expert can appreciate and some £2.99 slop from Tesco that tastes the same to the layman but at the end of the day they both get you pi**ed.

I think Lauren may have suggested in hypnotised Richard Hammond fasion the 911 is the quickest thing ever which of course it isnt, but raw speed is just the tip of the iceberg when it comes to appeal of certain cars, alot of people cant get there head around that.
User avatar
Lauren
IMOC Committee
Posts: 38632
Joined: Mon Dec 13, 2004 5:37 pm
Location: Greater Manchester
Contact:

Re: Rev2 tubby vs 911 GT2

Post by Lauren »

skinthespin wrote:

I think Lauren may have suggested in hypnotised Richard Hammond fasion the 911 is the quickest thing ever which of course it isnt, but raw speed is just the tip of the iceberg when it comes to appeal of certain cars, alot of people cant get there head around that.


Well i didn't say that, in fact thats not really what i meant at all.. as an experience as a usable track car (ie not something stupid that breaks every 3 minutes) and as a road car, the GT3RS perhaps presents the pinnacle of this. How I define that is very much based around the many other facets (of which speed is just one) that make up such a car.

I agree, most cannot seem to get their head round the fact that there is a lot more to this than simply what it says on paper.
2020 GR Yaris - Circuit Pack :lover:
fizz
Posts: 3761
Joined: Mon Jan 10, 2005 11:33 pm
Location: Bradford West Yorks

Re: Rev2 tubby vs 911 GT2

Post by fizz »

quigonjay wrote:


was looking forward to watching that but the wonky camera made me dizzy after about 10 secs :shaking2:


It was better than a slap in the face for me man.. :mrgreen:
Post Reply

Return to “Driving Experiences”