Help with insurance please

Ive posted about this before, very good response from you all,

But this time its really hit me!
Current car is rev 2 MR2 1992 no mods good alarm ECT.

I had to claims last year cry


Jan UN insurueded driver in a 4x4 reversed into me.

Next I had a Celica GT R stolen aggravated twoc.

Direct line have quoted

£1080 and others up too 2k.

I have 7 years NCPD my Mr2 is a nice car but in reality its worth 1500 at the most.

Where can I get sensible quote.

I had policy of

£525 ill the proof of no claims was sent, they the above, they wanted 900 quid more.

Dont get me wrong I understand how insurance sort of works, but what is the point in being fully comp if im going to get shafted later